What Is Old World Pepperoni?

Attention all foodies and lovers of authentic flavors! Are you tired of the same old toppings on your pizza or sandwiches? 

Look no further because today, we are diving into the world of old world pepperoni. This traditional cured meat has been a staple in many cuisines for centuries and continues to be beloved by people all over the world. 

In this blog post, we will explore the history, production process, and unique qualities that make old world pepperoni stand out from its modern counterparts. Keep scrolling down to know!

What Is Old World Pepperoni?

Let’s start with the definition – What is old world pepperoni?  

The term “old world” in old world pepperoni refers to one kind of American pepperoni use of natural casings, usually the stomach lining of sheep. This is the “old” Italian method of creating salami, which uses chiles, pork or beef, and natural casing. 

Also known as “pepperoncini” or “dry-cured pepperoni,” this type of salami is a dry sausage made from pork and beef. It is seasoned with a variety of spices such as paprika, black pepper, fennel, and garlic, giving it a distinct smoky and spicy flavor. 

Unlike modern pepperoni, which is made with a combination of pork, beef, and poultry, old world pepperoni is made solely from high-quality cuts of pork and beef. This gives it a richer taste and texture that its mass-produced counterpart can’t replicate. 

Origin Of Old World Pepperoni

The origins of old world pepperoni can be traced back to the early 1900s in the Mediterranean region, specifically Italy. The Italian word “peperone,” which means bell pepper, is whence the name “pepperoni” originates.

However, in Italian cuisine, “pepperoni” refers to a type of sweet pepper rather than a meat product. It is believed that old world pepperoni was brought to the United States by Italian immigrants and didn’t become a classic American pizza topping until the 1950s.

It quickly gained popularity among Americans and has since become a staple topping on pizzas, sandwiches, and charcuterie boards. 

What Kind Of Ingredients Are There In Old World Pepperoni?

As mentioned earlier, old world pepperoni is made from high-quality cuts of pork and beef. The meat is typically ground, mixed with spices, and then stuffed into a casing before being cured.

The most common spices used in old world pepperoni include paprika, black pepper, fennel, garlic, and cayenne pepper. Some producers also add red wine or vinegar to give it a tangy kick. 

The type of casing used can also vary, with some producers using natural hog casings and others opting for collagen or cellulose casings

Regardless of the ingredients and methods used, one thing remains constant – old world pepperoni is made with care and attention to detail, resulting in a truly authentic and flavorful product.

What Are The Factors That Make Old World Pepperoni Unique?

Several distinct factors set old world pepperoni apart from its contemporaries; they include:

1. Natural Casing: old world pepperoni’s natural casings, primarily sheep’s stomach lining, contribute to its distinctive texture. This characteristic cupping effect is a signature trait not found in most modern pepperoni.

2. Dry-Curing Process: The dry-curing method employed in its production allows for a concentration of flavors and a firmer texture. This process involves aging the pepperoni for an extended period, which imbues it with a complex spicy and sweet flavor profile.

3. Spice Blend: The specific blend of spices, including paprika, black pepper, fennel, garlic, and sometimes cayenne pepper, offers a depth of flavor. This blend not only provides heat but also layers of aromatic complexity.

4. Meat Quality: Made exclusively from high-quality cuts of pork and beef, old world pepperoni forsakes fillers, or additional poultry. This focus on quality ingredients ensures a richer, more authentic taste and texture.

5. Smoke Flavor: The traditional method of smoking or incorporating smoked spices adds another layer of flavor that distinguishes old world pepperoni from its modern counterparts. This smoky nuance complements the meat and spices, rounding out its flavor profile.

Together, these factors make old world pepperoni a preferred choice for those seeking an authentic and flavorful ingredient for pizzas, sandwiches, and charcuterie boards. 

The Reason Why Cooked Old World Pepperoni “Cup”?

If you’ve ever had old world pepperoni on your pizza, you may have noticed that it tends to “cup” when cooked. This means that the edges of the pepperoni slices curl up, creating little cups that trap the delicious juices and oils from the meat. 

This unique characteristic is due to the way old world pepperoni is made. The combination of high-quality meat, hand-mixing of spices, and a long curing process allows the fat to distribute evenly throughout the salami.

When cooked, this causes the edges to curl up, creating delicious cups that add an extra layer of flavor and texture to your pizza!

How Can We Make Old World Pepperoni? 

While old world pepperoni is best left to the experts, it is possible to make your version at home. However, be prepared for a long and tedious process behind it.

– Step 1: Choose premium meat cuts, mostly pork but occasionally mixed with beef. The choice of meat is quite important because it determines the overall flavor of the pepperoni. 

– Step 2: The meat is then ground and mixed with various spices, which can vary depending on personal preference. The real magic starts after the meat is spiced – the curing process. 

– Step 3: The meat is placed in a casing, usually natural or artificial, then hung to cure for weeks. The curing process can take quite a long period and requires proper temperature control and air circulation to achieve the desired result.

Once the pepperoni is fully cured, it’s ready to be sliced and enjoyed!

Tips For Cooking With Old World Pepperoni

We will provide you with some tips so that you can make the most of this tasty ingredient; here are some: 

1. Preheat your pizza stone: Bake your pizza stone at 475°F (245°C) for at least 30 minutes to get the ideal crust and uniformly cooked toppings.

2. Cut it thin: Using smaller slices of old world pepperoni helps the flavors blend in well with the other components.

3. Empty extra grease: Take out your pizza from the oven and use a paper towel to wipe off any extra grease that may have gotten on your pepperoni. This will guarantee a properly balanced bite and keep your pizza from getting unduly oily.

4. Combine with other toppings: Fresh veggies like bell peppers, onions, and mushrooms, as well as light, creamy cheeses like provolone or mozzarella, complement the strong flavors of old world pepperoni.

5. Cooking time: Since old world pepperoni tends to have a higher fat content, give the pepperoni a little more time to crisp up and release its wonderful flavors.

Where Can We Buy Old World Pepperoni?

As I have mentioned, the process of making old world pepperoni is so challenging that it may take weeks and proper equipment to achieve the desired result, so you can just try it at local delis or specialty stores. 

There are a few places you can go in pursuit of real old world pepperoni, including:

1. Pizzeria: Many local pizzerias use their homemade pepperoni in their dishes. It’s worth asking if they make it themselves and what spices they use to get a taste of the real thing.

2. Online: With the rise of online shopping, you can now find many authentic old world pepperoni options available for purchase online. Just make sure to read reviews and ratings before making a purchase.

3. Butcher Shops: Visit your local butcher shop and ask if they sell any homemade cured meats, including pepperoni. You may even be able to watch them make it in-house!

4. Upscale Supermarkets: Many upscale supermarkets now offer a variety of specialty cured meats, including old world pepperoni. Check the deli or meat counter for options.

How To Store Old World Pepperoni?

To ensure the freshness and quality of your old world pepperoni, it is important to store it properly. 

If pre-sliced pepperoni is what you’ve bought, be sure to move it into an airtight container or tightly seal it with plastic wrap before it goes into the fridge. Doing so helps to keep air away from the meat, preventing it from becoming dry.

If you have purchased a whole stick of old world pepperoni, you can leave it in its original packaging or wrap it in plastic wrap before placing it in the refrigerator. 

It is important to keep the pepperoni refrigerated and consume it within 3-4 days for best quality. Alternatively, you can also freeze old world pepperoni for longer storage. 

Make sure to slice it into smaller portions before freezing to make it easier to thaw and use. Frozen pepperoni can last up to 3 months in the freezer.


In conclusion, old world pepperoni is a delicious and versatile cured meat that can be used in various dishes. From traditional Italian favorites to unique and creative recipes, there are countless ways to incorporate this savory ingredient into your meals. 

Just remember to store it properly and seek out authentic options for the best flavor and quality. So next time you’re at the deli or grocery store, don’t hesitate to grab a pack of old world pepperoni and get cooking!

Leave a Comment